Conviction of Dara Singh in the murder of Pastor
Graham Stewart Stains (September, 2003) and his two
minor children comes as a small respite in the present
scenario where the perpetrators of communal violence
generally do not get punished. It is rare that the
prosecution makes the case properly and then deterrent
punishment is awarded. It is worth recalling here that
Dara Singh instigated the village youth and led their
mob to torch the Pastor and his two sons who were
sleeping in a jeep out in the open on the night of
22nd Jan 1999.
This act shook the nation so much that when the then
President Dr. K.R. Narayanan said that this is an act
from the world's inventory of black deedsand that it is a monumental aberration which went against the
traditions cherished by all Indian's he was
articulating the shock and anguish of average Indians.
Since Dara Singh was associated with Bajrang Dal, none
other than Madanlal Khurana a cabinet minister
resigned in disgust saying that there is enough proof
that the murderer was from Bajrang Dal. At the same
time in an operation cover up, Mr.L.K. Advani, the BJP
supreme, Home minister, asserted that he knows the
Bajarang dal too well and they cannot indulge in any
violence. The major attempt to put a lid on this act
came from the delegation of ministers comprising of
M.M. Joshi, Biju Patanaik and George Fernandes. This
trio visited the site for two hours and declared that
the murder is part of the international conspiracy to
destabilize the BJP led NDA Govt. At the same time VHP's Ashok Chowgule stated that Stains invited this
act due to his activities of conversion which the
natives resented and have done him to death. This was
the thinking of most of the segments of RSS
affiliates.
In the wake of this episode Wadhava commission was
appointed to investigate this crime. Though the brief
of this commission was very narrow still it did come
to the conclusion that Pastor Stains was not involved
in the acts of conversion. He was mainly a leprosy
worker. The population of Christians in the area where
he was working did not show any significant rise. It
was 0.27% in 1971 and was 0.31 in 19991. Again from
1991 to 1998 the rise in population was a biological
one rather than due to conversions. This is in
contrast to the claims of RSS ideologues who maintain
that Pastor was doing the conversion work. It is
laudable that the widow of Pastor Stains, Gladys Stains, has forgiven the culprits of her husband and
children's murder and has dedicated herself to carry
on the anti-leprosy work which her husband had
initiated.
This single episode demonstrates the deeper designs of
those pursuing communal politics and agenda for their
vested interests. It has been popularized from last
many a decades and more so during the last few years
that Christian missionaries are converting the
gullible, poor adivasis to Christianity, that this is
supported by the international funding, that this
conversion is the cause of secessionist activities in
the North East. One is struck by the timing of
beginning of anti-Christian violence from 1998. During
this year alone there were 116 attacks on Christians,
which is more than the number of attacks which took
place in all the previous years put together. This was
the year when BJP led NDA coalition was ruling in the
center. Since then the number of such attacks went up
for next three years or so. The accusations against
Christian missionaries have come up during last few
decades only. As such in a democratic country, since
religion is the private matter of the individual, it
is immaterial whether people from different religions
are trying to spread their religion to others or not.
As such it is ironical that Christianity, which is
older in India than in many a countries in the west,
is being called a foreign religion. As such the
percentage of Christian community in India has been
formed over a period of around fifteen centuries and
in the year 2001 their population stood at 2.18%. Also
there has been constant decline in their population
during last four decades, 2.60 (1971), 2.44 (1981),
2.32 (1991). While this core statastics is questioned
on the ground that there are many crypto Christians, a
new innovative term, who 'hide' their religion to
avail of social facilities. One is aghast at this
argument. How many privileges and other reservations
are available for low caste now? Can so many
Christians not declare their religion to take benefit
of reservation? Since when did they start hiding their
religion? This argument defies all the logic.
The statistics of North Eastern regions is flashed
regularly. Here the overall population being low, it
has no bearing on the total number of Christians in
the country. In the total population of close to 21
million Christians it is less than 2 millions, and
they are being projected as a danger in the North
Eastern region. Their adopting Christianity from the
tribal cults is a matter of their own choice. The
north eastern ethnic issue is deliberately being
projected as the one related to religion.
Interestingly, the major terrorist outfit ULFA, one of
the militant groups of NE, is not a Christian outfit.
The state of Manipur which has the Hindu majority is
also the state which has the highest militancy in that
region. India is a Nation in the making and faced with
many ethnic challenges. Confusing ethnicity and
religion is another ploy which the dominant political
streams are indulging in. A very low level propaganda
is being indulged in to demonize the Christian
missionaries about their methods, miracles etc. While
demonizing the Christian missions in far flung areas
the Christian activities in cities around educational
institutions and health related work are being totally
ignored. Are all the Christian missionaries of the
same mould? There are many sects amongst Christians,
like any other religion, and their practical
activities are not uniform. Surely some of them might
be doing the conversion work, bur so far as their work
is done in the framework of Indian constitution it
should not worry us. Even in states where the
anti-conversion laws have been brought in hardly any
cases have been registered against the Christian
priests for doing illegal conversion work.
One must reiterate that working in the constitutional
limits is as much the right of Christian missionaries
as of any other preacher. The campaign of Gharvapasi
in which tribal are converted to Hinduism is as much a
conversion. It is looked up as a laudable act as it is
presumed that adivasis are Hindus. To regard them as
Hindus is the cleverest ploy of RSS politics. If
religion is determined by one's holy books, prophets,
festivals, places of pilgrimage, and the clergy,
Adivasis by no stretch of imagination can be called as
Hindus. But again their taking to Hinduism is their
right as much as it is their right to take the
Christianity or Islam or any other religion for that
matter. The issues around conversion are political
issues and have nothing whatsoever to do with religion
or Nationality. In democratic set up to assert that
only people belonging to a particular religion or
religions are nationalists is the biggest insult to
our constitution. Hindutva after getting emboldened by
post babri demolition surge has undertaken anti
Christian attacks and attack on conversions in order
to consolidate it own self by projecting Christians as
threat to the Hindu Nation. Surely the contribution of
Christians, Muslims in freedom struggle and Nation
building is as much as that of Hindus. To cast
aspersions on any particular religion for secessionism
or for being anti-national is the act which will
weaken the unity of the nation. It is time we wake up
to the false propaganda being spread by RSS and its
affiliates and bring the national agenda back to
solving the unresolved issues facing the country be
they ethnic, or the one's related to the dignified
survival in the society.
|