Thirukkural, a saintly work in Tamil, of our Great Philosopher,
Thiruvalluvar, contains valuable solutions for our materialistic
as well as philosophical issues and is also capable
of curing many ills of the society. It gives answers
for social and economic problems irrespective of the
time, present or future. One such verse is being analysed
here with reference to a specific economic concept,
'business cycle or trade cycle'.
Alternate occurrences of upswings and downswings in
economic activities are known as trade cycles. Many
prominent economists have explained this phenomenon
both in non-monetary and monetary terms. The psychological
explanation given for trade cycle emphasizes that the
outlook about the future as bright or gloomy leads to
hectic or slowed down business activities. As a cure
they say the mindset of the business people or people
in general is to be changed to view the future as bright
or gloomy according to the needs or requirements of
the economy. This is the non-monetary explanation.
The monetary explanations given Hawtrey and Heyak insist
that it is the flow of capital that either stimulates
and activates the economic activities or depresses and
pulls down these activities. They suggest that appropriate
regulation of the supply of money is the cure for such
economic disorder.
The Kural,
¦À¡Õ¦ÇýÛõ ¦À¡ö¡ Å¢Çì¸õ
þÕÇÚìÌõ
±ñ½¢Â §¾ÂòÐî ¦ºýÚ
makes it clear and explains the importance of Capital/money/credit,
as it could remove the dull and gloomy conditions prevailing
in the economy and create the needed mindset. It is
prescribed by the economists of recent times that injecting
money supply or withdrawing it from the society in the
desired dose could either activate or deactivate the
economic activities. Such activation or deactivation
is needed to take the economy to prosperity or to check
it from suffering depression or setbacks, the two phases
of trade cycle viz., expansion and contraction.
Thiruvalluvar is of the view that capital is capable
of removing the darkness/misery in the economy caused
by depression. This concurs with the monetary theories
propounded by Hawtrey and Heyak the noted economists.
Let us look at the verse in a little more detail.
By the term 'porul' (¦À¡Õû)
Valluvar might have meant wealth, which in the economic
parlance may be taken as 'capital' (Ó¾ø,
ãľÉõ), capital in the form of money or bank
credit.
'Poyya Vilakkam' (¦À¡ö¡
Å¢Çì¸õ) means unfailing light, a light giving
hope for a bright future, a 'beacon'.
By the term 'enniya theyathu sendru' (±ñ½¢Â
§¾ÂòÐî ¦ºýÚ), he means flow of capital into the
required sector/section of the economy or nation even
foreign countries. It may also be taken as flow of capital
in the desired direction or sector or in accordance
with the plan in a planned economy.
'Irularukkum' (þÕÇÚìÌõ)
means that such capital flow into different sectors
will remove the dull or gloomy climate and create in
the minds of the investors or people in general an optimistic
view about the future/ the scope and opportunities for
investment and drive away all the fear about investment
and the yield there from. Thus it will lead to what
is called recovery and ultimately prosperity of the
economy.
Prof. Von Heyak is of the view that the imbalance in
investment / use of capital that is over investment
will lead to acceleration of economic activities in
the economy and hence there will be fluctuations in
the economic activities. He also stresses through his
theory that flow of money as investment either in excess
or dearth of it causes serious consequences in the economy.
Thus, Thiruvalluvar's verse has relevance to the monetary
versions of trade cycle. Further more, the verse could
also be read with reference to the 'psychological' theory
of business cycle according to which, 'it is the optimistic
or pessimistic outlook of the people that causes economic
fluctuations - the upswings and downswings'. In this
context, it may be interpreted that 'poyya vilakkam'
(¦À¡ö¡ Å¢Çì¸õ) meaning
an unfailing light, may be taken as the optimism - looking
at the brighter side of the phenomena/ incidents. Irul
(þÕû) may be taken
as pessimism, the darker side, the negative outlook.
Capital acts as unfailing light injecting confidence
in the minds of people and it is 'irularukkum' i.e.,
it is capable of removing darkness, the fear of risk
and loss and gives hope.
Thus, Valluvar's verse concurs not only with materialistic
outlook of the modern economists but also their psychological
outlook and holds good even in a modern planned economy.
In summary, Thiruvalluvar considers, 'porul' capital
or money as 'poyya vilakku', a beacon that develops
hopes and optimism and 'irularukkum' will remove the
gloom (from among the people or the business community)
by 'enniya theyathu sendru' (flowing into the needed
or desired sector /nation).
|